8/10
simple but cute, I like the green. (IMG:style_emoticons/default/lalagrin.gif)

7.5/10

The avatar is pretty nice. And the random avatars for the sig is a neat concept.

Avatar is to plan color wise and dosn't stand out, font is a bit eck. But over all alright.
Signature is more appropriate, older style photoshop trends with a simple font- though the colours seem to present an annoying pixalation glow. Image itself is fine- 7/10

5/10

There isn't much on it. The pics are pretty small and what not. But it's alright.

Sig: 5/10

The girl's picture on the right cuts off on the left side of her and it looks odd. Also the text on the left corner is slightly hard to read where it isn't on his face.
the Shape.. oh that shape. It would have looked better in a standard square. (But thats just me.)
The black shadow thing all around the signature is slightly off, by that I mean there isn't really black in the sig then it has that around it.


avi: 8/10

again with the back shadow thing , but its not bold, its opacity must have been turned down.
the shape is okay with it, but for me a standard square would have worked, buuut The picture of the two is cute :)

Set: 8.75/10

Good, but I see just a little bit of room for improvement. Under the circumstances, text is great. The use of the c4d came out perfect, lighting is excellent. However, I would've scaled the render down a little bit and moved it to the right, just a bit to have a bit of a fuller picture. It looks (around the hood) that you were using a star stock of sorts. Sometimes for a fuller effect, play around with the filter setting so it's not on lighten (or whatever you are using.) I actually tend to get stock photos of nebulas that the NASA website has so when you play with the filter settings you get some additional color.

So, things you could've added or changed. This is really opinionated of me, but this sig I think could've used a bit more dramatic lighting or some sort of simple effect fractal in addition to the c4d to make it a bit more dream like I suppose? The one place where you really fell flat on this sig is the border. It's uneven at the bottom in comparison to the right and top, and the way it goes below the render is a little bit weird. :(

HOWEVER! Very nice sig. You are starting to combine your style and that effect-y c4d style which is nice. I don't really have a style so I shouldn't be talking. :X But you have really developed as a gfx artist. Well done.

yea border was a fail D: using the square select tool not the best idea D:

---

10/10
Tofu's work is amazing and she really used the picture and butterflies well. adding the splatters and dots is great and the lighting it perfect :D

9.5/10 (IMG:style_emoticons/default/lalaexdee.gif) But the picture would look better if it was a bit to the right. XDDD

6.5/10
Everything looks pixely.

9/10

Good lord. The effects are amazing, but the fact that there are two of Beat and I can't see his face on the other one is kinda odd.

You have a unique style, keep utilizing it. >8D

10/10 very unique and cool great job

9.5/10

Really good, I just don't know what the text means.

10/10 very cool and the text means I love the animals it is french tee hee

10/10

Very nice. It's a nice concept, and nee-chan made it pretty. :3

oui 10/10 tres bien olala tres belle

7/10
I think more could have been done with it.

Time to be a critic. MUAHAHAHAHAHAH!

Well first of all I comment you on your gradient text. That must be a h-e-l-l-o operator of a lot of BBCode. Anyway.

first of all, color is great. So are effects, you know, it's awesome. A few things: as of late, a lot of your renders are too far blended in to the background. I understand that concept, but you are only going halfway with it I guess. Either blend em in all the way or don't do it at all. Other than that, it looks nice. I like the textures, only thing is the B there. I'd use a bit more detailed typography to the left of the darker render.

You know, on second thought I don't really mind the blending. Just the effects over the second render are a bit strange.

And have you moved into my set shop yet? D;

10/10

8.5/10

Alright, well I really like the colors and I think you placed Rinoa rather well. Those icy/feathery effects really blend the whole thing together, but... those two checkered stripes at the top and bottom remind me way too much of how a transparent background looks in gimp and make the whole thing look like it's kind of unfinished. I'm not too crazy about the border either.

9.5/10

HS did a good job. The only thing is some stray smudges here and there. :3